9.21.2009

italian, all day long

This is the year Maddy would start American kindergarten.  We have access to an American kindergarten with excellent kindergarten teachers.  I've seen one or two in action;  it's a place I would like for my kid to be.

Except.
Except, Except, Except.





She makes her way to school with her dad on September 2.
She missed the actual first day of school because she vomited during the night.
I later realized that the vomiting was due to anxiety.


We both strongly believe that she needs to learn the Italian language, to know the Italian people.  We know that the only way that this will happen is if she attends Italian schools.  She certainly won't learn any Italian worth speaking from us!  Instead of starting kindergarten this year, she will remain in the Italian system; she is in the final year of the Italian preschool or asilo.  

This choice of an Italian education, my friends, is no easy task, for a host of reasons, the least of which is our less-than-stellar Italian skills.  (Actually, our language skills are a little better than the average bear, at least of the American bears that we know.)  Perhaps I'll blog a bit more about what makes this choice difficult as the year progresses.  One example was the start of school.  Maddy was enveloped with intense anxiety -- anxiety that had never before surfaced, anxiety that led to sleepless nights & vomiting, anxiety that made me rethink my "I believe this is best" confidence, anxiety that caused crying and clinging as we dropped her off each day at a place she has attended since she was about one year old.


 Upon arrival, she removes her shoes for slippers or non-skid socks,
a task that she is finally able to complete on her own.


Finally at the end of the week, she confided:  "I don't like going to school because at school I have to be Italian all day long."  She speaks Italian.  She speaks it well.  She has even begun to read a bit in Italian.   She does not speak it as well as the other six (yes, I wrote "six") Italian children in her class.  For Maddy, this is a huge problem.  It's just Maddy, her little five-year-old personality.   What can I say -- it's in her genes.  It bothers her when she doesn't understand a word or when she can't speak as quickly as the others.  She doesn't realize that all the other kids don't understand all of the vocabulary of adults or story books either.  Like any child she sometimes stutters or has to search for words or phrases in English, but this just doesn't bother her like it does in Italian.

She is five, so she finds absolutely no consolation in the fact that she is able to communicate in two languages.  We do.  We carry on. We deal with a child who is sometimes unhappy to go to school, to school where she has to be "Italian, all day long."

Weeks 2 & 3 have been much better, by the way.

10 comments:

Anonymous said...

Ciao Dana , mi sembri tanto preoccupata, e questa tua ansia, assolutamente giusta, non devi pero' trasferirla su Maddy.Se tu sei forte e convinta delle tue decisioni, lo sara' anche lei. non farti tutti questi problemi per le due lingue,avra' modo di perfezionarle con il tempo!
E la scuola materna che lei frequenta e' un posto bellissimo, le maestre sono molto preparate e sapranno guidare la bimba in questa fase di passaggio .

Un saluto a Maddy ! Luisa

Anonymous said...

It must be hard. Ultimately, if your plan is to stay in Italy for a while, it does make sense for her to attend an Italian school. How about having someone come to your house and play and read to her in Italian? Just a few hours, one-to-one play aimed at building her vocabulary (but mainly her confidence)? I did something like that once with the 5 year old son of some Danish friends who'd moved in the area: it worked very well.
Hope week 4 started better.

Jeannette said...

Awh...Maddy.
Although I´m not a child anymore I do relate. If I´m having a party where everyone is German I feel the anxiety of being the odd duck out. So my heart goes out to her .... but it will get better!
♥ Jeannette

Samantha said...

My daughter too is five years old and attending her last year of Italian materna. It can be frustrating for them that they can't express themselves as quickly as the others but another language and culture is a true gift for her! If you decide to send her on to Italian primary school you will see how her Italian will blossom. By the end of first grade they are reading and writing Italian. Just amazing! My ten year old daughter has flourished in the Italian system and I know my five year old will as well. Keep smiling and trust your decisions!

Dana said...

Luisa,
Yes, I know that the teachers in her asilo are great. We love them all very much & are especially pleased with Marzia, Maddy's main teacher. It's a warm and nuturing environment that we hope to continue with next year.

Francesca,
I always appreciate your perspective. Our days are so long already that I can't imagine more added in the evenings. Maddy will start an Italian dance class next week & we are making an effort to be among Italians more.

Jeannette,
I know. Every time I am the only English-speaker in the group....I get anxious. It gets better every time AND it's usually when I learn the most.

Samantha,
I agree about the gift.I know that she will pull through...in time.

Thanks to everyone for your comments. I enjoyed the conversation.
Dana

Anonymous said...

Ohhh, my heart goes out to her and you, too. I know the feeling of wanting to take away all that makes them so anxious. It will get better, one way or another. She has two wonderful parents at home who will make sure it does. I love you and miss you terribly. Give Maddy many hugs and kisses from me.

jane said...

hey dana- i know what you are going through- just wondering if a school is right brings on tons of stress- then add in a second language... i can imagine what you are feeling-
my kids were born in spain. they always went to spanish schools and they never had a problem- then again their father is spanish. i always thought if i had had a choice i would have sent them to an american school. i just like the educational system much more ( they teach you how to think, instead of always memorizing) so for me it´s about the education- and italian isn´t a hard language (not like german- remind me to tell you about my friend who moved to germany with her two small children...) i´m sure she has an excellent base and then you can always get her a tutor later on. ok i´m rambling- i hope you don´t mind my two cents...

anita tedaldi said...

Hopefully she will adjust as time goes by. I can only imagine how tough it is for a child to switch from one world to another. It was very tough for me even as a teenager and I ended up trying to assimilate and put the Italian aside.
I didn't speak Italian to my children for a long time - only now starting back.
If you listen like you do I'm sure you'll help her each step of the way!
BTW are you guys permanently in Italy? Or do you eventually plan on getting back in the US?

Dana said...

Truth is that without the school system, she just won't learn Italian. Most of our friends speak only English; in our home we speak only English. If we live here, she needs to learn Italian. It's quite a handicap if she does not. We plan to be here for a long time -- at least until retirement & perhaps beyond. She could live a life complete with t-ball, dance lessons, musical theater, movies, piano lessons, etc. on the American military base. Ummm...not exactly what I had in mind for my child when I moved here. How well-rounded would that be? I don't like all aspects of the Italian way of elementary school. It is different, very different .... HOWEVER, even though the methods are different, the kids still learn. I'm not so sure when or if she will transition to the American system. I am happy to have the choice, though.
sigh....she'll be okay. :)

Nella mia soffitta... said...

Dear Diana...
thanks to visit my blog.. I'm so happy to meet you!
Well... I think that is a big opportunity for your child to learn to speak two languages... for me it's difficult just to speak italian!!! :-)
Your Maddy is young.. she need to receive trust.. she need to take confidence with this new "condition"...
Passed the first hurdle you'll see that everything will be easier and amazing too...
A hug